Skip to Main content
  • Proper Pizza

Currently not accepting online orders

Proper Pizza 2283 Ringling Boulevard

2283 Ringling Boulevard, Sarasota, FL
Pizza Menu🍕
Main Menu 🍽️
Catering Menu 🚗
N/A Beverages 🥤
Happy Hour Food
Happy Hour Drinks

Pizza Menu🍕

14" Pizzas

  • 14" Plain Cheese Pizza

    Added to fulfill sizing request.
  • Regular Pizza 14"

    Red Sauce, shredded mozzarella
    $16.00
  • Pep Pizza 14"

    Red Sauce, shredded mozzarella, pepperoni
    $18.00
  • Honey Badger 14"

    Red Sauce, shredded mozzarella, pepperoni, herbed ricotta, four chili blend, Mike's hot honey
    $24.00
  • Buffalo Soldier 14"

    Shredded mozzarella, buffalo sauce, buffalo chicken, choice of ranch or blue cheese
    $24.00
  • Parmageddon 14"

    Red sauce, shredded mozzarella, breaded chicken cutlet, fresh mozzarella, parmigiano reggiano, basil.
    $24.00
  • White Iverson 14"

    Smoked mozzarella, herbed ricotta, garlic oil, parmigiano reggiano, parsley
    $22.00
  • EBTKS 14"

    Red Sauce, shredded mozzarella, pepperoni, Italian sausage, peppers, onions, mushrooms, olives.
    $24.00
  • Meaty Boi 14"

    Red Sauce, shredded mozzarella, pepperoni, Italian sausage, ham, wagyu meatballs
    $24.00
  • Proper Pizza 14"

    $24.00
  • Queen Margherita 14"

    Red Sauce, fresh mozzarella, basil, parmigiano reggiano, extra virgin olive oil.
    $24.00
  • The Goat 14"

    EVOO, shredded mozzarella, goat cheese, roasted garlic, honey
    $22.00
  • Tie Dye Pizza 14"

    Shredded mozzarella, vodka sauce, marinara sauce, pesto sauce, parmigiano reggiano
    $22.00

18" Pizza

  • 18" Plain Cheese Pizza

    Added to fulfill sizing request.
  • Regular Pizza 18"

    Red Sauce, shredded mozzarella
    $24.00
  • Pep Pizza 18"

    Red Sauce, shredded mozzarella, pepperoni
    $26.00
  • Honey Badger 18"

    Red Sauce, shredded mozzarella, pepperoni, herbed ricotta, four chili blend, Mike's hot honey
    $34.00
  • Buffalo Soldier 18"

    Shredded mozzarella, buffalo sauce, buffalo chicken, choice of ranch or blue cheese
    $34.00
  • Parmageddon 18"

    Red sauce, shredded mozzarella, breaded chicken cutlet, fresh mozzarella, parmigiano reggiano, basil.
    $34.00
  • White Iverson 18"

    Smoked mozzarella, herbed ricotta, garlic oil, parmigiano reggiano, parsley
    $32.00
  • EBTKS 18"

    Red Sauce, shredded mozzarella, pepperoni, Italian sausage, peppers, onions, mushrooms, olives.
    $34.00
  • Meaty Boi 18"

    Red Sauce, shredded mozzarella, pepperoni, Italian sausage, ham, wagyu meatballs
    $34.00
  • Proper Pizza 18"

    $34.00
  • Queen Margherita 18"

    Red Sauce, fresh mozzarella, basil, parmigiano reggiano, extra virgin olive oil.
    $34.00
  • The Goat 18"

    EVOO, shredded mozzarella, goat cheese, roasted garlic, honey
    $32.00
  • Tie Dye Pizza 18"

    Shredded mozzarella, vodka sauce, marinara sauce, pesto sauce, parmigiano reggiano
    $32.00

Sicilian Pizza

  • Sicilian Pizza Plain (10" Square)

    Red Sauce, shredded mozzarella
    $18.00
  • Sicilian Pizza Double Pepperoni (10" Square)

    Red Sauce, shredded mozzarella, double pepperoni, parmigiano reggiano, fresh basil
    $22.00
  • Sicilian Pizza Tie Dye (10" Square)

    Shredded mozzarella, vodka sauce, marinara sauce, pesto sauce, parmigiano reggiano
    $24.00
  • Sicilian Pizza Buffalo Soldier (10" Square)

    Shredded mozzarella, buffalo sauce, buffalo chicken, choice of ranch or blue cheese.
    $24.00

XL Pizzas

  • XL Plain Cheese Pizza

    $21.00
  • XL Pepperoni Pizza

    $23.00
  • XL Veggie Pizza

    $30.00
  • XL Supreme Pizza

    $32.00
  • XL Meatlovers Pizza

    $32.00
  • XL Hot Honey Pizza

    $34.00
  • XL Margherita Pizza

    $30.00
  • XL White Pizza

    $32.00
  • XL Buffalo Chicken Pizza

    $34.00

Other Pizzas

  • 10" Plain Cheese Pizza

    Added to fulfill sizing request.
  • Burrata Bomb (Grandma Square)

    Red Sauce, four pepper chili blend, pepperoni, burrata, Mike's hot honey
    $32.00
  • Brooklyn Square (16" Square)

    Seasoned crust, red sauce, fresh mozzarella, basil, extra virgin olive oil, parmigiano reggiano
    $28.00
  • Nduja Pie

    Red sauce, nduja sausage, burrata, crushed pistachios, parmigiano reggiano.
    $32.00
  • Teddy's Truffle Pie

    Shredded mozz, whipped herbed ricotta, sautéed chanterelle mushrooms, black summer truffles, truffle honey, sea salt

Kids Pizza

  • Kids Cheese Pizza

    Kid's portioned cheese pizza
    $10.00

Main Menu 🍽️

Starters

  • HTB

    Heirloom tomatoes, burrata, pesto, extra virgin olive oil, balsamic reduction, crushed pistachios and micro basil. Served with toasted focaccia
    $14.00
  • Fries With Benefits

    White truffle, parmesan cheese, parsley, fried in pure beef tallow
    $12.00
  • Papa Chef’s Meatballs

    Homemade 100% grass-fed wagyu beef meatballs, marinara, parmigiano reggiano
    $12.00
  • Squid Games

    Lightly breaded calamari, shishito peppers, served with marinara and roasted garlic aioli
    $15.00
  • Sunshine Caesar

    Little gem lettuce, parmigiano reggiano, Sicilian breadcrumbs, house made anchovy caesar dressing
    $14.00
  • Twisted Sisters

    Garlic knots, house made garlic parm sauce, side of marinara
    $8.00
  • Rosemary’s Baby

    Fluffy and crispy house made focaccia
    $10.00

Wings

  • Wings (10 Piece)

    10 wings with your choice of sauce
    $18.00
  • Wings (20 Piece)

    20 wings with your choice of sauce
    $35.00

Sandwiches

  • The Russell

    Choice of hand breaded chicken cutlet or grilled chicken breast, chopped romaine, Sicilian breadcrumbs, freshly grated parmigiano reggiano, house made Caesar dressing, focaccia
    $16.00
  • The Big Z

    House made wagyu beef meatballs, marinara, shredded mozzarella cheese, parmigiano reggiano, seeded roll
    $18.00
  • The G

    Pepperoni, salami, mortadella, capicola, prosciutto di Parma, provolone, shaved lettuce, sliced tomato, sweet onion, roasted red pepper, pepperoncini, oil and vinegar, focaccia
    $16.00
  • The Alfie

    All natural turkey, house made pesto aioli, roasted red peppers, fresh mozzarella cheese, arugula, focaccia
    $16.00
  • The Matty B

    Pistacchio mortadella, burrata, pistachio cream, parmigiano reggiano, crushed pistachios, focaccia
    $16.00

Calzones

  • Calzone

    3 topping max. Deep fried or baked with mozzarella and ricotta
    $15.00

Pasta

  • The Sir

    Tiger shrimp, spicy tomato sauce, Calabrian chili
    $26.00
  • The Mam

    Imported pecorino romano, tellicherry black pepper
    $19.00
  • Why's It Called Alfredo?

    Garlic confit, fresh thyme, creamy alfredo sauce, parmigiano reggiano
    $19.00
  • La Rosa

    Heirloom cherry tomato, vodka sauce, parmigiano reggiano
    $19.00
  • Meaty Gurl

    100% grass fed wagyu beef, celery, carrot, tomato sauce
    $22.00
  • Tie Dye Pasta

    Hand breaded harvestland organic chicken cutlet, marinara, vodka sauce, basil pesto, burrata, micro basil, parmigiano reggiano, side of fresh pasta with vodka sauce
    $30.00
  • Traditional Pasta

    Hand breaded harvestland organic chicken cutlet, marinara sauce, fresh mozzarella cheese, micro basil, parmigiano reggiano, side of fresh pasta with marinara sauce
    $30.00
  • The Baked Z

    Rigatoni, bolognese, ricotta, mozzarella, parmesan, baked to perfection
    $22.00
  • Nonna Nola

    Bell peppers, onions, cajun cream sauce
    $19.00
  • Kids Pasta

    Buttered or marinara
    $8.00

Desserts

  • Mini Cannoli

    $2.00
  • New York Style Cheesecake

    Topped with a strawberry compote and house made whipped cream
  • Pistachio Panna Cotta

    Topped with roasted pistachios and house made whipped cream
  • Tiramisu

    Lady fingers, mascarpone cream, espresso
  • Sicilian Cannoli

    Housemade sweet ricotta with chocolate chips
  • Blood Orange Olive Oil Cake

    Served with whipped ricotta and honey

Catering Menu 🚗

Starters

  • Meatballs - Half Pan

    $40.00
  • Meatballs - Full Pan

    $80.00
  • Garlic Knots - Half Pan

    Served with marinara sauce
    $30.00
  • Garlic Knots - Full Pan

    Served with marinara sauce
    $60.00
  • Bone In Wings - 20pcs

    Sauces: Mild, Hot, Honey BBQ, Buffalo-BBQ, Garlic Parm. Served with Bleu Cheese or Ranch Dressing.
    $34.00
  • Bone In Wings - 50pcs

    Sauces: Mild, Hot, Honey BBQ, Buffalo-BBQ, Garlic Parm. Served with Bleu Cheese or Ranch Dressing.
    $80.00
  • Boneless Wings - 20pcs

    Sauces: Mild, Hot, Honey BBQ, Buffalo-BBQ, Garlic Parm. Served with Bleu Cheese or Ranch Dressing.
    $34.00
  • Boneless Wings - 50pcs

    Sauces: Mild, Hot, Honey BBQ, Buffalo-BBQ, Garlic Parm. Served with Bleu Cheese or Ranch Dressing.
    $80.00
  • Heirloom Tomato and Burrata Salad - Half Pan

    Served with Homemade Pesto Sauce, Micro Basil
    $50.00
  • Heirloom Tomato and Burrata Salad - Full Pan

    Served with Homemade Pesto Sauce, Micro Basil
    $100.00
  • Caesar Salad - Half Pan

    Romaine, Homemade Caesar Dressing, Shaved Parmesan Cheese, Croutons.
    $35.00
  • Caesar Salad - Full Pan

    Romaine, Homemade Caesar Dressing, Shaved Parmesan Cheese, Croutons.
    $70.00

Pasta

  • Penne Alfredo - Half Pan

    $60.00
  • Penne Alfredo - Full Pan

    $120.00
  • Penne Vodka - Half Pan

    $60.00
  • Penne Vodka - Full Pan

    $120.00
  • Penne Pesto - Half Pan

    $60.00
  • Penne Pesto - Full Pan

    $120.00
  • Penne Bolognese - Half Pan

    $70.00
  • Penne Bolognese - Full Pan

    $140.00
  • Penne Marinara - Half Pan

    $50.00
  • Penne Marinara - Full Pan

    $100.00
  • Penne Arrabiatta - Half Pan

    $50.00
  • Penne Arrabiatta - Full Pan

    $100.00
  • Baked Ziti - Half Pan

    $75.00
  • Baked Ziti - Full Pan

    $150.00

Desserts

  • Tiramisu - Half Pan

    $40.00
  • Tiramisu - Full Pan

    $80.00

N/A Beverages 🥤

Soda

  • Coke Can

    $2.00
  • Sprite Can

    Corrected from 'Spite Can'
    $2.00
  • Diet Coke Can

    $2.00

Water

  • Bottled Water

    $2.00

Happy Hour Food

Happy Hour

  • Tendies

    Vodka fondue
    $9.00
  • Pizza Montanara

    Fried pizza dough, red sauce, fresh mozz, truffle oil, parmigiano reggiano, basil
    $8.00
  • Mini Charcuterie Board

    Prosciutto, mortadella, parmesan, goat cheese, olives, almonds, fig jam, toasted focaccia
    $12.00
  • Chicken Parm Sliders (2)

    Chicken cutlet, marinara, fresh mozz, basil, garlic knot bun
    $9.00
  • Bruschetta

    Heirloom cherry tomatoes, EVOO, roasted garlic, fresh basil, balsamic reduction, parmigiano reggiano, micro basil.
    $8.00
  • Nduja Mussels

    PEI mussels, nduja, heirloom cherry tomatoes, shallots, garlic, white wine, fresh thyme, meyer lemon, served with grilled focaccia
    $12.00

Happy Hour Drinks

Wine

  • Wine (TBD) Glass

    Wine selection to be determined.
  • Wine (TBD) Bottle

    Wine selection to be determined.

Tiramisu - Full Pan

$80.00
Request advisory
We'll do our best to accommodate special requests but may not be able to honor all substitutes. Extra charges may apply.
1

Proper Pizza Location and Hours

(518) 391-0218
2283 Ringling Boulevard, Sarasota, FL 34237
Closed • Opens Tuesday at 8AM
Toast logopowered by toast
  • Terms of Service
  • |Privacy Statement